%
CapRateCity
Free cap rate calculators for every US market
← All Rankings

Best Mid-Size Cities (100K-500K) for Rental Investing (2026)

Mid-size cities (100K-500K) are the goldilocks zone: big enough for economic diversity and property management options, small enough for strong rent-to-price ratios. Many experienced investors find their best returns in this category.

1
Jackson, MS5.8% cap rate
$140K median$920/mo rent5.8% cap rate-0.2% growth
2
Mobile, AL5.8% cap rate
$155K median$980/mo rent5.8% cap rate0.1% growth
3
Montgomery, AL5.7% cap rate
$165K median$1,020/mo rent5.7% cap rate0.2% growth
4
Birmingham, AL5.5% cap rate
$185K median$1,120/mo rent5.5% cap rate0.3% growth
5
South Bend, IN5.4% cap rate
$155K median$980/mo rent5.4% cap rate0.3% growth
6
Shreveport, LA5.4% cap rate
$155K median$950/mo rent5.4% cap rate-0.3% growth
7
Macon, GA5.3% cap rate
$155K median$980/mo rent5.3% cap rate0.2% growth
8
Evansville, IN5.3% cap rate
$155K median$950/mo rent5.3% cap rate0.2% growth
9
Dayton, OH5.2% cap rate
$140K median$960/mo rent5.2% cap rate-0.1% growth
10
Tuscaloosa, AL5.2% cap rate
$195K median$1,120/mo rent5.2% cap rate0.8% growth
11
Columbus, GA5.2% cap rate
$175K median$1,080/mo rent5.2% cap rate0.4% growth
12
Akron, OH5.2% cap rate
$145K median$980/mo rent5.2% cap rate-0.2% growth
13
Toledo, OH5.1% cap rate
$135K median$920/mo rent5.1% cap rate-0.3% growth
14
Columbia, SC5.0% cap rate
$205K median$1,150/mo rent5.0% cap rate0.8% growth
15
Fort Wayne, IN4.9% cap rate
$185K median$1,080/mo rent4.9% cap rate0.7% growth
16
Peoria, IL4.9% cap rate
$125K median$880/mo rent4.9% cap rate-0.3% growth
17
Topeka, KS4.9% cap rate
$155K median$980/mo rent4.9% cap rate0.2% growth
18
Little Rock, AR4.9% cap rate
$195K median$1,100/mo rent4.9% cap rate0.5% growth
19
Fayetteville, NC4.9% cap rate
$195K median$1,120/mo rent4.9% cap rate0.8% growth
20
Lafayette, LA4.8% cap rate
$210K median$1,150/mo rent4.8% cap rate0.6% growth
21
Syracuse, NY4.8% cap rate
$155K median$1,020/mo rent4.8% cap rate-0.2% growth
22
Augusta, GA4.8% cap rate
$180K median$1,050/mo rent4.8% cap rate0.5% growth
23
Springfield, IL4.8% cap rate
$135K median$920/mo rent4.8% cap rate0.1% growth
24
Baton Rouge, LA4.8% cap rate
$220K median$1,200/mo rent4.8% cap rate0.5% growth
25
Roanoke, VA4.7% cap rate
$195K median$1,100/mo rent4.7% cap rate0.3% growth
26
High Point, NC4.7% cap rate
$195K median$1,100/mo rent4.7% cap rate0.6% growth
27
Lansing, MI4.7% cap rate
$165K median$1,020/mo rent4.7% cap rate0.3% growth
28
Rockford, IL4.7% cap rate
$135K median$920/mo rent4.7% cap rate-0.2% growth
29
Amarillo, TX4.7% cap rate
$175K median$1,100/mo rent4.7% cap rate0.7% growth
30
Tulsa, OK4.6% cap rate
$195K median$1,100/mo rent4.6% cap rate0.6% growth
The CapRateCity Report
Weekly market analysis: highest cap rate cities, emerging markets, and deal breakdowns. Free, no spam.